Reposted – great poem

He has control,I don’t know the length of sorrow.He has given,I don’t know the depth of happiness.He is a guide,I don’t know life’s journey.He is a saviour,I don’t know the extent of spirituality.He is a giver,I don’t know my destiny.He is unknown,I don’t know the path of heaven.He is interpreted,I don’t know my meaning.He is

His Control

Love and destruction. Learning from children.

Reflecting on what Donald Winnicott found from studying infant development.

Recently, I was reading a passage by the mid-twentieth-century paediatrician and psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott that made me think rather differently about God. Winnicott was interested in how we become ourselves. Not simply how we develop a personality, but something more fundamental: how we come to experience ourselves as real, living in a world inhabited by other people who exist independently of us. 

Succinctly—how the self becomes.

His answer was surprising. It seems that in order to discover the reality of someone we love, we may first need to try to destroy them. It sounds alarming, but bear with me.

The Infant Who Thinks It Is God

Winnicott—profoundly influenced by his supervisor, Melanie Klein—believed that an infant begins life without a clear distinction between itself and the world. The baby experiences hunger, and food appears; it experiences discomfort, and someone responds. At first, there is no fully developed sense of a separate person providing these things. The infant inhabits a world of near-omnipotence, in which its wishes and the responses of its surroundings are not yet clearly distinguished.

Gradually, of course, reality intrudes. The mother does not always appear immediately. She is not simply an extension of the infant’s wishes; she has needs of her own. This establishes the mother as both “good” (when present) and “bad” (when withdrawn).

And this is where Winnicott introduces his rather startling idea of destruction. In unconscious fantasy, the infant seeks to destroy the object of its dependence as a test of its capacity to be held. Crucially, the mother survives. She does not disappear, retaliate, or withdraw her love. Through this experience, the infant begins to discover something extraordinary: the mother exists independently of its own wishes and fantasies.

She is real. And because she is real, the relationship can become real, too.

In his 1969 paper The Use of an Object, Winnicott describes this imagined discovery:

“The object is first made real through aggressive destruction; and this of course, makes experience of the object feel real to the self… The subject says to the object: ‘I have destroyed you,’ and the object is there to receive the communication. From now on the subject says: ‘Hullo, object! I destroyed you. I love you. You have value for me because of your survival of my destruction of you.'”

Winnicott called the nurturing context that makes this development possible the “holding environment.” His famous idea of the “good-enough mother” was not about perfect parenting. Quite the opposite. It was about providing enough security, responsiveness, and continuity for the child to gradually encounter a world that does not simply conform to its wishes.

The important point is that the child does not discover itself in isolation. We do not become ourselves alone. The self becomes real through its encounter with another who is also real.

Creating and Destroying the Parental God

If this is how we mature psychologically, perhaps it is also how we mature spiritually.

Consider our cultural conception of the divine. We—Christians, Muslims, and Jews alike—have largely created an archetypal father figure; a parental deity whom many now revile. But maybe this is a necessary stage. As we seek revelation, perhaps we must first create, and then attempt to destroy, God in the image of a parent.

Other religious traditions have long explored conceptions of ultimate reality that do not depend upon the image of a parental deity. Hindu philosophical traditions, for example, include understandings of Brahman as the ultimate reality underlying existence, sometimes understood as beyond all personal attributes and distinctions. While Hinduism also has rich traditions of personal devotion, its philosophical diversity reminds us that the Western image of God as an authoritative father is not the only possible way of approaching the sacred.

Isn’t it probable that God is not male, or parental at all? Perhaps what matters is not whether God is male or female, parental or impersonal, but that we are connected. Being of one substance. A part, yet apart.

Finding that God is still there, patiently loving, surviving our destruction—it is then that we can relax into acceptance.

Awakening to Existential Love

The most important question is whether we are capable of encountering a reality that does not simply reflect ourselves. That is a question of spirituality, but it is also a question of psychological maturity.

Can we love another person without needing them to become what we want? Can we accept a world that exceeds our understanding and control? And can we allow our most cherished beliefs to be challenged without assuming that everything they were trying to express must therefore disappear?

I find myself returning to Winnicott’s extraordinary image of the infant who destroys the mother in fantasy, only to discover that she is still there. It is through the mother’s survival that she becomes real to the child.

Perhaps in this age of materialism and the repudiation of the divine, we stand on the threshold of awakening to existential love. A love that survives our destruction.

If politicians meant what they said?

Can We Judge Politicians by What They Say?

A couple of days ago I wrote a blog proposing two tests for a moral society — and, by extension, moral politics.

The first was Rawls’ veil of ignorance: would we consider a society just if we didn’t know what position we ourselves would occupy within it?

The second was what I called the Christ test: “By their fruits ye shall know them” (Matthew 7:20). In other words, judge people not by what they profess, but by what they actually do.

I concluded that this presented a problem for democracy. We could only really judge the morality of politicians after they had been in power, when their actions had borne fruit.

But something has occurred to me since.

What if speaking is itself a form of action?

Philosophers such as Martin Buber and Maurice Merleau-Ponty, and psychotherapists such as Carl Rogers, understood that dialogue is not simply an exchange of pre-existing ideas. It is through our encounters with others that our understanding of ourselves and the world develops.

As Buber famously put it:

> “All real living is meeting.”

And Merleau-Ponty argued that thought is not simply formed privately and subsequently expressed in language. Rather, thought can be realised through expression itself.

Interestingly, there is experimental evidence for this.

Psychologists have identified what they call the question–behaviour effect. A meta-analysis of 116 tests found that simply asking people about their intentions produces a small but measurable change in their subsequent behaviour (Wood et al., 2016).

Another review of 94 tests found that people who articulated specific plans about when and how they would act were substantially more likely to follow through (Gollwitzer & Sheeran, 2006).

What we say doesn’t merely reflect what we think. It can help shape what we become.

Of course, these studies concern particular kinds of intentions and behaviour, not political speeches. But they suggest something important: perhaps we shouldn’t dismiss politicians’ words as mere rhetoric while waiting to see their fruits.

Their words may themselves be part of the process through which those fruits develop. And political speech also shapes the understanding and behaviour of those who listen.

So perhaps I was too hasty. What politicians say really does matter, not simply because it reveals their intentions, but because speaking may help create the reality that follows.

Which leaves us with a rather awkward problem.

How do we distinguish politicians whose words express genuine convictions from those who are simply using language to manipulate us?

Perhaps we need a third test.

Now, how on earth do we devise one of those?!

References

● Buber, M. (1923/1970). I and Thou. Translated by Walter Kaufmann. Scribner.

● Merleau-Ponty, M. (1945/2012). Phenomenology of Perception. Routledge.

● Rogers, C. R. (1961). On Becoming a Person. Houghton Mifflin.

● Wood, C. et al. (2016). The Impact of Asking Intention or Self-Prediction Questions on Subsequent Behavior: A Meta-Analysis. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 20(3), 245–268.

● Gollwitzer, P. M. & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation Intentions and Goal Achievement. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69–119.

Never truly lost

Like so many others, I have known the ache of losing those I love—my father, my mother, and my brother among them. It was the death of my mother thirty years ago that first drove me to search for answers within my grief. Where had she gone? Is there life beyond death? What is our true purpose? If God exists, why must this life hold so much pain?

Over the decades, that search has led me to a quiet certainty: there is a purpose to our existence, and we remain forever connected to the ones we have lost. The poet Rupert Brooke expressed this beautifully in his poem, “The Soldier.” The short verse below draws inspiration from his lines “ and think this heart all evil shed away…a pulse in the eternal mind, no less” . I offer this hoping to comfort anyone currently navigating the raw, overwhelming pain of grief.

For thou hast gone my love

Released to be

A pulse in the  eternal mind, no less

It’s thus that we

Flow forward on our journey, thee with me

As part my heart, one part

One melody

Within the universal song we’ll rest

In harmony

With that life, whose loving sets us free.

Practical Tests for a Moral Society

When societies come under strain, the impulse to fracture along national or geographic lines can be powerful. It is more than an impulse – the reversion to protect our own is visceral. (At least that is how I experience it). Yet political nationalism often turns attachment to home into suspicion of neighbours and contempt for minorities. Societies do not heal by narrowing belonging. Renewal requires cooperative, structural policies that address the root of collective anger: severe economic abandonment.

The scale of that abandonment is stark. In Great Britain, the wealthiest 10% of households held £1,200,500 or more in wealth in 2020–22, while the least wealthy 10% held £16,500 or less. In the UK, the richest 56 people now hold more wealth than 27 million people combined. Faced with such insecurity, political leaders too often divert anger towards migrants, minorities, or neighbouring nations rather than confronting structural injustice.

Two Tests for a Just Society

To move beyond blame and judge how we should rebuild, two moral tests are useful.

The first is John Rawls’s “veil of ignorance”. Rawls asks us to design society without knowing whether we will be born rich or poor, powerful or powerless. From that position, no just society would allow vast wealth to accumulate at the top while millions live in insecurity. Inequality is tolerable only when it benefits the least well-off.

The second is Christ’s warning: “By their fruits ye shall know them.” It requires us to judge politicians and economic systems not by patriotic rhetoric, but by their effects on human dignity.

Judging the Recent Past by Its Fruits

Applying these tests to recent UK governments—assessed roughly a decade after they left power—reveals stark differences in outcome:

 Margaret Thatcher: She came to power on the back of economic turmoil arising from industrial dispute under the previous labour government. This era prioritised market deregulation over protections for the least advantaged, contradicting the Rawlsian premise. Its fruits included a sharp rise in inequality: overall poverty rose to around one in four people by the mid-1990s, pensioner poverty increased from 13% to 43%, and child poverty more than doubled.

 Tony Blair: New Labour raised the economic floor through the minimum wage and increased social investment. Child poverty fell by around 600,000 children, and absolute pensioner poverty declined significantly. Yet overall income inequality barely shifted, as top incomes continued to rise. Alas, the end result was economic destitution.

 David Cameron: Austerity eroded support for the least well-off, placing much of the burden of fiscal consolidation on vulnerable communities. Central government funding for local authorities fell by over 50% in real terms between 2010–11 and 2020–21. The consequences include persistent child poverty and long-term damage to public health, reflected in British 19-year-old boys falling from 28th to 39th in global height rankings between 1985 and 2019.

The Time Horizon of Justice

For structural repair to last, it needs to be build on strong and practical foundations. There are no short cuts. Did the Russian revolution, with all of it’s bloodshed lead to a just society – or new Czars by another name? Redistribution, or any major policy shift, must be phased over a measured time horizon so that we can build on what is working amongst our own peoples. A Rawlsian society raises the floor through gradual uplift, not abrupt and punitive extraction.

Radical, yes – but not sudden. There are calls to levy immediate taxes on pockets of wealth. Oil and banking could simply depart. Sudden extraction from income-poor pensioners would force many to sell their settled home in their old age. It is the fear of such changes that provokes fierce resistance. A long-term, generational vision of fairness avoids punitive shocks and is more likely to command the broad public support needed for durable change.

To reverse the damage of the last decade, we must recognise that geographic and constitutional rifts—whether North versus South or Scottish and Welsh separatism—distract from a shared condition of economic abandonment. They drain energy from housing, education, and social care, serving those who benefit from a divided working class.

Rather than divide the map, a better politics must widen belonging. Practical Christian socialism—grounded in solidarity, the dignity of labour, and carefully managed redistribution—can offer both moral clarity and broad public appeal. By rejecting scapegoating and committing to cooperative repair, we can build a society that passes the test of its fruits.

Therefore, ask yourself..

Who should we lend our vote to? We only have the words, rather than actions of politicians, so we can only guess at the fruits. We can though look to similar politicians in the past and judge where they led.  I, personally would not support anyone who appeals to division – any kind of nationalism, to self-interest or who canvas our vote on the basis of blaming the “other”.

Is there a way in which which compassionate policies can be allied to practical economic management? Let us hope so.

References

 Bible: The Gospel According to Matthew, 7:16. (King James Version).

 Oxfam GB (2026): Billionaire wealth jumps three times faster in 2025 to highest peak ever. (Corresponds to the claim about the richest 56 people holding more wealth than 27 million people combined).

 Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) (2013 / Various Years): Living Standards, Poverty and Inequality in the UK. (Corresponds to historical poverty rate changes during the Thatcher and Blair administrations).

 Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) (2024): UK Poverty Report. (Corresponds to data on child poverty rates and the impact of the 2010s austerity programme).

 Local Government Association (LGA) (2020): Local government funding: moving the conversation on. (Corresponds to the 40% reduction in central government funding for local authorities).

 NCD-Risk Factor Collaboration (NCD-RisC) (2020): Height and body-mass index trajectories of school-aged children and adolescents from 1985 to 2019 in 200 countries. The Lancet. (Corresponds to the drop in global height rankings for British 19-year-old boys).

 Office for National Statistics (ONS) (2025): Household total wealth in Great Britain: April 2020 to March 2022. (Corresponds to the £1,200,500 vs £16,500 household wealth statistics).

 Rawls, J. (1971): A Theory of Justice. Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. (Corresponds to the “veil of ignorance” philosophical framework).

Feeling Our Way: Why Emotion, Not Logic, Is the Starting Point of Human Experience




Adapted from Solms and Panksepp, 2012, p. 150 Figure 1 “Nested Brain-Mind Hierarchies”

We tend to treat logic as the crown jewel of human consciousness. In business, design, and policy, we prioritise rational arguments, verbal communication, and structured data. But when it comes to understanding human behavior, values, and how we relate to the world, logic is actually late to the party.

If we want to understand what truly drives us, we have to start where consciousness itself begins: with our feelings.

Two Pathways of the Mind

Thinking and feeling are not just different ways of processing information—they are fundamentally distinct aspects of consciousness governed by entirely separate pathways in the brain.

 The Older Brainstem (Emotions): Evolutionarily speaking, our emotional infrastructure is ancient. Formed in the deeper, older brainstem, emotions operate through non-verbal, sensory “languages.” We don’t sense feelings as words; we feel them as physical, visceral states.

 The Newer Neocortex (Thoughts): Rational thinking happens in the neocortex, a much newer evolutionary development. Verbal communication and structured logic live here, giving us the ability to reason, analyse, and communicate complex concepts.

While we often view these two systems as rivals, they exist in a continuous feedback loop. Rational thought informs emotion, and emotional learning reshapes logic—a process of circular causation mediated by experience.

The Primacy of Affect

Neuroscientific research, including work by Mark Solms and Jaak Panksepp, reveals a startling truth: feelings are primary.

Thought actually derives its consciousness from the brainstem. In other words, without the raw, sensory spark of emotion, rational thought wouldn’t even have a stage to perform on. Affect is the foundation upon which all our understanding, choices, and personal values are built.

When we try to force human values into mental models made entirely of words and rigid logic, we miss the foundation that holds the entire structure up.

Reclaiming Embodied Understanding

As neuroscientist Antonio Damasio famously wrote, “Feelings, along with the emotions they come from, are not a luxury.” They are essential survival tools that guide how we navigate, evaluate, and find meaning in our environments.

Rather than trying to translate every emotional reaction into neat verbal formulas, we need to respect our embodied understanding. True rationality doesn’t mean ignoring emotion; it means aligning our logical thinking with our felt experience.

Whether we are designing spaces, shaping organizations, or trying to understand human connection, we cannot purely logic our way to the answer. We need to sense how people genuinely relate to their surroundings.

Ultimately, to move forward meaningfully, we have to feel our way.

AI and the Unselfish Gene

Evolution is one of the best-supported ideas in science. The question is not whether evolution happens, but whether the familiar story of life as a ruthless contest among selfish genes is enough.

Over the past fifty years, discoveries in palaeontology, genetics, microbiology, and ecology have revealed a richer picture. Life does not evolve only through competition; it is also shaped by cooperation, partnership, environmental influence, and integration.

This matters far beyond biology. As humanity enters the age of artificial intelligence, the evolutionary story we carry shapes the future we imagine. If life is only a struggle for dominance, AI looks like a rival, perhaps even an existential threat. But if evolution also works through cooperation, integration, and symbiosis, another possibility opens: humans and intelligent machines may be able to co-evolve. We may be about to enter a golden age.

Beyond the Selfish Gene

What most people think of as Darwinism is in fact a subset: Neo-Darwinism. This concept arose in the first half of the last century, in a milieu of reductionism, materialism, and competition. It presents evolution as a process driven by random genetic variation and natural selection. In this system, genes change by chance; bodies, or phenotypes, express those genes; and the organisms best suited to their environment leave more descendants.

This is a powerful model, and it explains a great deal. But as a complete account of evolution it is too narrow. It leaves insufficient room for other forces that can organise, coordinate, and transform living systems.

The twentieth century often treated genes as the commanding centre of life. Richard Dawkins’ The Selfish Gene, published in 1976, gave this view its most public expression. Its central metaphor was simple and brilliant: organisms could be seen as vehicles built by genes to help those genes survive and replicate.

For many readers, including myself at the time, thisseemed blindingly obvious. It seemed to offer a clean, elegant explanation of life’s complexity. But metaphors can illuminate and distort at the same time. The selfish-gene idea made competition vivid, but it also encouraged a view of nature in which cooperation, relationship, environment, and consciousness were pushed to the margins.

The accumulation of evidence over the past 50 years has shown that view to be incomplete, and at times misleading.

A Personal Perspective

When I studied Vertebrate Evolution at Cambridge in the mid-1970s, I remember the subject feeling very different from the physical sciences. Physics and chemistry seemed to rest on repeatable experiments. Evolutionary palaeontology, by contrast, involved reconstructing vanished worlds from fragmentary evidence: bones, strata, fossils, and the stories we built around them.

That made the field intellectually exciting and creative, because it allowed for interpretation. The fossil record is real, but our reading of it is never free from assumptions.

When Dawkins published The Selfish Gene, I was initially an admirer. Like many others, I saw sociobiology as a thrilling leap forward. I even mistook it, at first, for something close to the evolutionary vision of Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, the French Jesuit thinker who saw evolution as moving toward greater complexity and consciousness.

Only later did I see the difference more clearly. Dawkins offered a gene-centred account of evolution grounded in material reductionism. Teilhard offered a vision of evolution as an unfolding movement toward integration, in which the process itself could act upon ideas as well as physical bodies. Teilhard represented this as a movement from the biosphere into the noosphere.

We do not have to accept every part of Teilhard’s vision to recognise that the gene-centred model is incomplete. The broader thrust of his thought—the movement toward greater integration—now looks less fanciful than it once did. Much of his writing in the 1950s anticipated the rise of the internet and of a planet-wide layer of transhuman intelligence.

Pierre Teilhard de Chardin

The Fossil Record: Change Often Comes in Bursts

A simple version of Neo-Darwinism imagines evolution as slow, steady, and gradual: tiny changes accumulating through countless generations.

Sometimes this happens. But the fossil record also reveals long periods of stability interrupted by comparatively rapid change.

Stephen Jay Gould and Niles Eldredge called it “punctuated equilibrium”. Species often appear in the geological record, remain relatively stable for long periods, and then change more rapidly during shorter bursts of evolutionary transition.

This does not mean that Darwin was wrong. It means that evolution is not always the smooth, gradual process many people imagine. Stability can give way to rapid transition, often under environmental pressure, ecological opportunity, or wider shifts in living systems. Some innovations also arise through hybridisation or symbiosis, where separate elements combine to create something new.

The history of life looks less like a straight line and more like a tree shaped by sudden growth, pruning, branching, and transformation.

Beyond Competition

The phrase “survival of the fittest” is often misunderstood. It is commonly taken to mean that nature is simply a war of all against all, with the strongest defeating the weakest.

But “fitness” in evolutionary biology means reproductive success in a particular environment. Sometimes that success comes through competition. But often it comes through cooperation.

Once fitness is understood in that broader sense, the narrower story begins to open up.

At the Boundary: Competition or Cooperation?

Peter Kropotkin argued in Mutual Aid that cooperation was not a sentimental exception to evolution, but one of its central forces. Konstantin Mereschkowsky proposed that complex life arose not only through competition, but through symbiosis: different organisms joining together and becoming something new.

For much of the twentieth century, such ideas sat outside the mainstream. Today, they look increasingly important.

Epigenetics: Genes Are Not Simple Switches

Epigenetics has changed how we think about inheritance.

DNA is often described as a blueprint, but this is misleading. A better image might be a script, a library, or a musical score. The same genetic material can be “played” differently depending on context.

Epigenetics studies the chemical tags and regulatory processes that influence whether particular genes are switched on or off. Diet, stress, toxins, behaviour, and environment can all affect gene expression. In some cases, these effects may even influence later generations.

This does not mean Lamarck was simply right in the old sense that a giraffe stretches its neck and passes on a longer neck to its offspring. But it does mean he was not entirely foolish to suspect that life experience and heredity might be connected.

The boundary between organism and environment is therefore more porous than classical theory allowed. Even the separation of species and individuals has begun to look less absolute.

Symbiosis: Life through Partnership

One of the most striking examples of cooperation is found inside our own cells.

Mitochondria, the tiny structures that help power our bodies, were once free-living bacteria. At some point in deep evolutionary time, they entered into partnership with other cells. That partnership became so successful that it helped make complex life possible.

This is the theory of endosymbiosis, developed most famously by Lynn Margulis. It shows that evolution is not only about one lineage defeating another. Often life advances in jumps when formerly separate organisms merge, collaborate, and become inseparable.

The same principle applies at larger scales. Human beings are not solitary biological units. We are ecosystems. Our bodies contain trillions of microbes that help digest food, regulate immunity, and influence health. The “individual” is therefore not as individual as it appears.

We are, in a literal biological sense, communities.

Cooperation as an Evolutionary Force

Cooperation appears throughout life.

Bacteria communicate chemically through quorum sensing. Fungi form underground networks with plants. Social insects build colonies that behave almost like superorganisms. Wolves hunt in packs. Human beings survive through language, culture, care, teaching, and shared memory.

Competition matters. But cooperation matters just as much. Often, the most successful systems are not the most selfish, but the most intelligently integrated.

This is why the selfish-gene metaphor now appears limited, even where it remains useful.

Evolution is therefore not merely a story of conflict. It is also a story of relationship.

Why Old Ideas Persist

Scientific ideas do not disappear the moment new evidence appears. They become embedded in textbooks, careers, institutions, public reputations, and cultural worldviews.

The gene-centred view of evolution became influential not only because it explained important facts, but because it offered a simple and compelling story. It fitted comfortably with a wider modern habit of seeing reality as mechanical, competitive, and material.

But good science must remain open to revision. When new evidence expands the picture, the theory must expand too.

This is the promise of the Extended Evolutionary Synthesis. It does not throw Darwin away. Instead, it places natural selection within a wider framework that includes development, environment, epigenetics, niche construction, cooperation, culture, and symbiosis.

In other words, the question is not whether Darwin mattered. Of course he did. The question is whether Darwinism, in its narrowest twentieth-century form, is enough.

Increasingly, it is not.

Why This Matters for Artificial Intelligence

This wider view matters now because artificial intelligence forces us to ask what kind of evolutionary story we believe we are living inside.

If life is fundamentally a competition among self-interested replicators, then AI looks like the next rival: faster, more connected, more rational, and perhaps ultimately dominant.

But if evolution also works through cooperation and symbiosis, then a different future becomes imaginable.

Human beings have always evolved with tools. Fire, language, writing, agriculture, cities, printing, electricity, and the internet all changed what we are. They did not merely extend human power; they altered human consciousness.

AI may be another such threshold.

The question is whether we approach it as enemy, servant, or partner. A purely competitive model pushes us toward fear: either we control the machine, or the machine controls us. A symbiotic model asks something deeper: how might human intelligence and artificial intelligence develop together in ways that enlarge both?

This is not a naïve optimism. AI carries real risks. Power, surveillance, inequality, dependency, and misuse are serious dangers. But fear alone is not a sufficient philosophy. We need a richer imagination.

Biology suggests that the future may not belong simply to the strongest competitor. It may belong to the most creative partnerships.

Toward a Larger Understanding of Life

The old image of the isolated individual is breaking down. Biology shows us organisms shaped by environments, genes regulated by experience, bodies composed of microbial partnerships, and species embedded in ecosystems.

We are not sealed egos moving through a dead mechanical universe. We are relational beings, formed by ancestry, community, ecology, technology, and consciousness.

That insight changes how we think about AI. Rather than seeing artificial intelligence only as an alien competitor, we might understand it as part of a larger evolutionary process: the emergence of new forms of connection, memory, and mind.

This does not require every reader to accept a religious interpretation. But it does invite a larger question: what if evolution is not only the history of competition, but also the history of separated things learning to belong to one another?

Teilhard de Chardin imagined evolution moving toward an Omega Point: a final convergence of consciousness. Others may describe the same intuition in secular language, as the gradual integration of life, intelligence, and awareness.

For me, that ultimate unity of consciousness is what I call God.

Whatever language we use, the lesson is the same. The future of life may depend less on selfishness than on symbiosis; less on domination than on relationship; less on the isolated gene than on the creative whole.

The Creative Whole

References & Notes

1. La Mettrie, J. O. de (1747). L’Homme Machine (Man a Machine). A foundational text of mechanistic materialism arguing that human mental processes are entirely physical and mechanical.

2. Dawkins, R. (1976). The Selfish Gene. Oxford University Press. Formulated the gene-centred view of evolution and sociobiology.

3. Teilhard de Chardin, P. (1955). The Phenomenon of Man. Harper & Row. Proposed that evolution is an ascending process leading toward increasing complexity and consciousness.

4. Eldredge, N., & Gould, S. J. (1972). “Punctuated equilibria: an alternative to phyletic gradualism.” In T. J. M. Schopf (Ed.), Models in Paleobiology(pp. 82–115). Freeman, Cooper & Co.

5. McShea, D. W., & Simpson, C. (2011). “The drive toward complexity in evolution.” Evolutionary Biology, 38(1), 78–94.

6. Darwin, C. (1859). On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. John Murray.

7. Lamarck, J.-B. (1809). Philosophie Zoologique. Formulated an early theory of inheritance of acquired characteristics.

8. Kropotkin, P. (1902). Mutual Aid: A Factor of Evolution. Heinemann. Argued that mutual support and cooperation play a major role in evolutionary success.

9. Mereschkowsky, K. (1905). “Über Natur und Ursprung der Chromatophoren imPflanzenreiche.” Biologisches Centralblatt, 25, 593–604. An early formal hypothesis of symbiogenesis.

10. Jablonka, E., & Lamb, M. J. (2005). Evolution in Four Dimensions: Genetic, Epigenetic, Behavioral, and Symbolic Variation in the History of Life. MIT Press.

11. Margulis, L. (1970). Origin of Eukaryotic Cells. Yale University Press. Developed the theory that eukaryotic organelles such as mitochondria and chloroplasts originated through bacterial endosymbiosis.

12. Zilber-Rosenberg, I., & Rosenberg, E. (2008). “Role of microorganisms in the evolution of animals and plants: the hologenome theory of evolution.” FEMS Microbiology Reviews, 32(5), 723–735.

13. Laland, K. N., Uller, T., Feldman, M. W., Sterelny, K., Müller, G. B., Moczek, A., Jablonka, E., & Wray, G. A. (2014). “Does evolutionary theory need a rethink? Yes, urgently.” Nature, 514(7521), 161–164.

14. Imanishi, K. (1941 / English translation 2002). The World of Living Things (Seibutsu no Sekai). Routledge. Introduced habitat segregation, or sumiwake, and a holistic view of ecological coexistence.

15. Teilhard de Chardin, P. (1964). The Future of Man. Harper & Row. Developed the concept of the Omega Point as a convergence of evolutionary and spiritual development.

 

Facing up to incompatible truths

Seemingly absolute truths can be absolutely incompatible. How can we make sense of this, do we simply have to make a choice of one over another? The issue may be our partial understanding; human perception grasping only fragments of a  larger reality. Rather than choosing between paradigms we should hold them in tension as a method to try to deepen understanding. 

I have wrestled with this in my struggles with belief because at the same time I do believe that Christ said he was THE way to life, yet Buddhism for example predated him and is also A way to life. How so? Do we have to make choices, for instance between science and religion?

Consider the following concepts from scientists and philosophers, which appear to be internally consistent, but mutually exclusive : 

  • Granularity or Continuity: Reality behaves as both discrete, granular particles (supported by Tim Palmer’s rational quantum mechanics *1) and yet as continuous waves (supported by Milo Wolff’s Wave Structure of Matter *2).
  • Or..Flow : David Bohm *3 and Alfred North Whitehead *4 argue the universe is an ongoing, emerging process rather than a collection of fixed, static objects.
  • Or..Relational : Thinkers like Einstein *5 , Buber *6 , and Merleau-Ponty *7 emphasize that reality is understood and created through relationships and participation, rather than existing as a self-contained absolute.

The poetic concept of “Incarnation,” as explored by T.S. Eliot in The Dry Salvages *8 , offers a way to reconcile these granular, wave-like, processual, and relational views. Eliot frames Incarnation not as an escape from reality, but as a union where opposing spheres—such as the finite and infinite, or time and eternity—are held together without losing their underlying tension. Just as quantum theory proposes that is our act of observation that crystallises infinite potential in this particular concrete reality. Ultimately, as Eliot illustrates with “the still point of the turning world” in Burnt Norton, opposites like stillness and movement are not contradictions to be but rather point toward some richer understanding.

The two poems, Dry Salvages and Burn Norton, are part of Eliot’s “Four Quartets”. These are a meditation on time and existence, where it is Christ who allows opposites to meet. It is through a seemingly impossible fusion where “tongues of flame are unfolded into the crowned knot of fire” that the “fire and the rose are one”; and thence release existence where “all shall be well and all manner of thing shall be well”.

It is in this way that I resolve a personal contradiction that I have struggled with. Christ said “I am the way the truth and the life, except by me shall no person come to God”. It has always seemed to me that this must necessarily be wrong. What then, about those before his birth, or who struggle toward light within other religious traditions. There is truth – I believe – within Hinduism and Buddhism. A Christian faith built on exclusion seems incompatible with the essence of my experience of Christ.

Perhaps though Christ is BOTH “the way to truth and life” AND “a way to truth and life”?

*1 Tim Palmer (Rational Quantum Mechanics / Invariant Set Theory): Palmer’s framework models quantum mechanics using fractal-like invariant sets in state space to resolve quantum measurement problems locally and deterministically. Explore his core research paper, Invariant Set Theory on arXiv, and his academic research index at the University of Oxford Physics Department.

*2 Milo Wolff (Wave Structure of Matter): Wolff posits that subatomic particles like the electron are not discrete solid spheres, but rather standing wave centers formed by converging and diverging spherical scalar waves. Read a summary of his wave-based cosmological equations on the Natural Philosophy Wiki entry for Milo Wolff.

*3 David Bohm (Wholeness and the Implicate Order): Bohm proposes that the universe is an undivided flux (“holomovement”) in which static objects are merely temporary explicate projections of an enfolded implicate order. Review the Wikipedia Summary of Wholeness and the Implicate Order and an architectural breakdown on Closer to Truth.

*4 Alfred North Whitehead (Process Philosophy / Process and Reality): Whitehead argues that the fundamental constituents of reality are not fixed material substances, but interconnected “actual occasions” of becoming. Read the reference guide in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy on Alfred North Whitehead and the structural outline of Process and Reality on Wikipedia.

*5 Albert Einstein (Relativity of Spacetime): Einstein established that space, time, and mass do not exist as absolute, static backgrounds, but as dynamic relationships defined by speed, gravitational fields, and reference frames. Read about these conceptual developments in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Early Interpretations of General Relativity.

*6 Martin Buber (I and Thou / Philosophy of Dialogue): Buber differentiates between the objectifying relation (I-It) and reciprocal, participatory encounters (I-Thou) through which genuine identity and reality are realized. Consult the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Martin Buber and the overview of I and Thou on Wikipedia.

*7 Maurice Merleau-Ponty (Embodied Phenomenology): Merleau-Ponty asserts that reality is never perceived from an abstract, detached exterior, but is continuously co-created through the body’s active participation in the world. Read the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry on Maurice Merleau-Ponty.

*8 T.S. Eliot (Four Quartets: Burnt Norton and The Dry Salvages): Eliot uses the concept of Incarnation and “the still point of the turning world” to articulate how timelessness and time, movement and stillness, intersect without canceling each other out. Read an summary of the poetic structures in Wikipedia’s Four Quartets overview and background notes in the Barbican Guide to Four Quartets