Reality as Candyfloss

(a shared verb, not a noun)

For years, I have held onto a specific image of how existence unfolds: imagine that we are all spinning around a shared spine of history, gathering and weaving the present moment out of the past, like sugar fibers winding into candy floss on a stick. In this view, we are not static objects placed inside an empty container of space. We are in a constant, active state of becoming, rather than simply being. link to Weaving Candyfloss

There was a fascinating article in this weeks New Scientist – entitled “Back to the Past” Link , which illuminates this image. In it Karmela Padavic-Callaghan’ explores Jacob Barandes’ new theory of how fundamental particles operate through deeply “history-laden” dynamics. For me, this incorporation of the past into physics is an absolute revelation. It makes immediate sense of Alfred North Whitehead’s Process and Reality (which frankly I have struggled to grasp) while simultaneously grounding the bizarre properties of the quantum universe.

Standard physics assumes the universe is “Markovian”—that the past can be discarded once you know the present. Barandes argues the opposite: particles carry the heavy, unbroken weight of their past trajectories with them. Suddenly, quantum entanglement isn’t “spooky action at a distance” violating the speed of light; it is two particles acting in perfect concert because they share a tightly coupled, historical origin. Wave function collapse ceases to be a mathematical glitch and becomes what Whitehead called concrescence—the exact moment a system integrates its historical trajectory and actualizes into a concrete, undeniable fact.

But how do these strange, highly individualized quantum histories scale up into the stable, shared reality we call “normal”?

At the smallest scales, individual history is paramount. But as things scale up, these isolated microscopic histories become subsumed into a vast, interactive collection. To understand how this transition shapes our actual lived experience, we have to look beyond physics to the French philosopher Maurice Merleau-Ponty.

Starting from the insights of Gestalt psychology, Merleau-Ponty realized that we do not experience reality as isolated minds processing data. In Phenomenology of Perception, he showed that reality is brought forth by the lived body, moving and experiencing in a continuous, reciprocal dance with the “other.” We do not just observe the world; we physically and spatially negotiate it together.

In his final, unfinished masterwork, The Visible and the Invisible, Merleau-Ponty took this dance to its ultimate ontological conclusion. He proposed that the perceiver and the perceived are not fundamentally separate. We emerge from a primordial, common substance—an elemental connective tissue of existence he called Chair (often translated as the “Flesh of the world”). We are not alien observers dropped into a mechanical universe; we are the universe folding back on itself to touch, see, and develop its own substance in unison.

This is where the physics, the process philosophy, and the phenomenology beautifully collide.

Barandes provides the microscopic mechanism: reality is built on a spine of retained history. Whitehead provides the transitional architecture: these individual historical events combine into a “societal concrescence,” a stabilized web of shared histories. And Merleau-Ponty gives us the human experience of that web: the Chair, the shared flesh of reality that we constantly develop in our dance with one another.

By continually grasping our history and moving together in the present, we co-create the macroscopic actual world. We are the universe in a state of becoming, actively spinning the shared candy floss of reality we call normal.

I think about.. therefore we are.

For three centuries, Descartes’ Cogito has led the world to think in terms of separation—cleaving subject from object, mind from matter. But this division is, ultimately, a fantasy.

As Merleau-Ponty recognized, everything is actually one. He spoke of the “flesh” of the world, where a simple act like sitting in a chair is a continuous process of co-creation as the body moves and interacts. Quantum physics tells us the same story: the Copenhagen interpretation reveals that the observer inextricably affects the observed precisely because they are part of the exact same system. The Indian Hindus have been right all along—the strict object-subject division is an illusion.

Thinking is plural. It involves subject (thinker) and object (idea). Reality is in the relationship between; it is not concrete or material. “I think, therefore I am” is incomplete. Better would be: I think ABOUT, therefore there is existence.

This isn’t my insight, but variously Einstein’s (relativity), Bion’s (the mind as apparatus to think pre-existing ideas), Whitehead’s (Process and Reality), and Buber’s (Ich und Du).

What we experience in this separated worldview is dis-integration. Alone we are: alone. Point-less. Together and between us lies the truth. Indeed, materiality is a chimera: we reflect each other, flowers of the same plant. Reality is in the honouring of the God in You, in the I-Thou rather than I-It.

“World is crazier and more of it than we think, Incorrigibly plural. I peel and portion A tangerine and spit the pips and feel The drunkenness of things being various.”

— Louis MacNeice

If politicians meant what they said?

Can We Judge Politicians by What They Say?

A couple of days ago I wrote a blog proposing two tests for a moral society — and, by extension, moral politics.

The first was Rawls’ veil of ignorance: would we consider a society just if we didn’t know what position we ourselves would occupy within it?

The second was what I called the Christ test: “By their fruits ye shall know them” (Matthew 7:20). In other words, judge people not by what they profess, but by what they actually do.

I concluded that this presented a problem for democracy. We could only really judge the morality of politicians after they had been in power, when their actions had borne fruit.

But something has occurred to me since.

What if speaking is itself a form of action?

Philosophers such as Martin Buber and Maurice Merleau-Ponty, and psychotherapists such as Carl Rogers, understood that dialogue is not simply an exchange of pre-existing ideas. It is through our encounters with others that our understanding of ourselves and the world develops.

As Buber famously put it:

> “All real living is meeting.”

And Merleau-Ponty argued that thought is not simply formed privately and subsequently expressed in language. Rather, thought can be realised through expression itself.

Interestingly, there is experimental evidence for this.

Psychologists have identified what they call the question–behaviour effect. A meta-analysis of 116 tests found that simply asking people about their intentions produces a small but measurable change in their subsequent behaviour (Wood et al., 2016).

Another review of 94 tests found that people who articulated specific plans about when and how they would act were substantially more likely to follow through (Gollwitzer & Sheeran, 2006).

What we say doesn’t merely reflect what we think. It can help shape what we become.

Of course, these studies concern particular kinds of intentions and behaviour, not political speeches. But they suggest something important: perhaps we shouldn’t dismiss politicians’ words as mere rhetoric while waiting to see their fruits.

Their words may themselves be part of the process through which those fruits develop. And political speech also shapes the understanding and behaviour of those who listen.

So perhaps I was too hasty. What politicians say really does matter, not simply because it reveals their intentions, but because speaking may help create the reality that follows.

Which leaves us with a rather awkward problem.

How do we distinguish politicians whose words express genuine convictions from those who are simply using language to manipulate us?

Perhaps we need a third test.

Now, how on earth do we devise one of those?!

References

● Buber, M. (1923/1970). I and Thou. Translated by Walter Kaufmann. Scribner.

● Merleau-Ponty, M. (1945/2012). Phenomenology of Perception. Routledge.

● Rogers, C. R. (1961). On Becoming a Person. Houghton Mifflin.

● Wood, C. et al. (2016). The Impact of Asking Intention or Self-Prediction Questions on Subsequent Behavior: A Meta-Analysis. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 20(3), 245–268.

● Gollwitzer, P. M. & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation Intentions and Goal Achievement. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69–119.